Family Chef Talk Forum banner
  • Welcome, guest! Are you ready to join the discussion? Click here!

Share Your Potluck Tips: What's Your Go-To Dish?

270 Views 23 Replies 7 Participants Last post by  Wooleybooger
Flower Food Tableware Plant Table
Potlucks are the perfect opportunity to show off your cooking skills while enjoying delicious food with friends and family. But let's be honest, we all have that one dish that we turn to time and time again when we need to impress.

Well...you might not but I sure do!

So, what's your go-to dish for a potluck? Is it a classic pasta salad, a savory quiche, or perhaps a homemade dessert that always steals the show?

Do you have a tried and true recipe you'd be willing to share? After all, good food tastes better when shared! 😊
See less See more
1 - 20 of 24 Posts

This ☝ used to be my go-to recipe when taking "something" to a gathering I attend a few times a year. It never fails to please and there are never leftovers to take home.

However, I no longer make these since my biggest fan passed away. The last time I made them was for his memorial service.

I tested another recipe for the get-together and I've been told that if I'm not bringing these with me then I shouldn't bother showing up. They are wonderful!

  • Like
Reactions: 1
Keto Cole Slaw
(original recipe from Jill Moody at Just A Pinch Recipes)

Ingredients

12 oz bag coleslaw blend (or shred your own; about half a large head of cabbage)
1/2 c real mayonnaise (no sugars; not "salad dressing")
1 1/2 Tbsp apple cider vinegar
1 tsp ground black pepper
1/2 tsp ground sea salt/kosher salt
1/2 tsp celery seed
1/2 tsp stevia or other sweetener
1/4 c chopped spring onion (optional)

Directions

1. Whisk mayonnaise, apple cider vinegar, pepper, salt, celery seed and sweetener in a large mixing bowl.
2. Add half of the cabbage mix, fold until all cabbage looks soaked.
3. Add the other half of the cabbage mix and the onions if you opted for them. Fold again until all cabbage has been gently moistened (It may look dry, but it won't be).
4. Refrigerate and stir it again in two hours. Then let it refrigerate for a minimum of 12 hours. Serve cold.

Never fails and rarely comes back as leftovers. It's a nice not-sweet alternative to the rich foods often served at potlucks.
See less See more
  • Drool
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I've been told I can bring anything I want as long as I make sure I bring cheesecake. They don't care what flavor it is, how cracked it might be or anything else. If I don't bring one I might as well stay home because they're not going to let me in the door.
  • Love
  • Wow
Reactions: 2
Used to be shrimp and grits when I lived in Virginia. I'll share my recipe later. Now that I'm back in Ohio it's Cincinnati chili. Philly cheesesteak casserole has been another I've used with a lot of approval.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Philly cheesesteak casserole has been another I've used with a lot of approval.
That sounds very interesting. Care to share?
  • Like
Reactions: 2
That sounds very interesting. Care to share?
I'll second the motion.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
  • Like
Reactions: 2
If I don't bring [a cheesecake] I might as well stay home because they're not going to let me in the door.
We were part of a group that often held potlucks (treats mostly but sometimes meals). One guy became famous for always bringing fresh pineapple, cut into tidbits with a toothpick in each piece. Pineapple Paul, we called him. The pineapple was welcome and he was a really nice guy. But I'd hate to be known by the food I bring to potlucks ("Oh, did Slaw Steve bring that?").
  • Haha
Reactions: 4
MY SIL always took 3 bean salad. Opening those cans was her part of the effort.

I don't have a dish, the wife takes petzel salad. She is very popular. :)
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Philly cheesesteak casserole is deceptively easy. I start with a box kit marketed by Velveeta. I sub steak for the hamburger meat they intend you to use. I throw in some extra peppers and onions because they are an afterthought in the kit. Otherwise, follow the box instructions. It's a 25 minute meal. It doubles well too.
  • Like
  • Helpful
Reactions: 3
A box kit? The only Velveeta product I see around here is their process cheese.
2
A box kit? The only Velveeta product I see around here is their process cheese.
Food Ingredient Recipe Cuisine Dish


Displayed near the Hamburger Helper and box mac and cheese. I wait for them to go on sale 3/$9. If I don't have some flank or sirloin sitting around, I might buy a package of this meat:
Ingredient Recipe Cuisine Dish Font

Occasionally I add mushrooms if I know I have a crowd that likes them. That is one of my other popular dishes: stuffed mushrooms. But I essentially follow a recipe that Cowboy Kent Rollins put out a few years ago: basically breakfast sausage, some peppers, and cheese to comprise the stuffing. One of my closest colleagues used to tell me, "I'll pay for the ingredients if you make a double batch of those mushrooms." And off to Harris Teeter I would go so I could get the good mushrooms.
See less See more
  • Helpful
  • Like
Reactions: 2
View attachment 1201

Displayed near the Hamburger Helper and box mac and cheese. I wait for them to go on sale 3/$9. If I don't have some flank or sirloin sitting around, I might buy a package of this meat:
View attachment 1202
Occasionally I add mushrooms if I know I have a crowd that likes them. That is one of my other popular dishes: stuffed mushrooms. But I essentially follow a recipe that Cowboy Kent Rollins put out a few years ago: basically breakfast sausage, some peppers, and cheese to comprise the stuffing. One of my closest colleagues used to tell me, "I'll pay for the ingredients if you make a double batch of those mushrooms." And off to Harris Teeter I would go so I could get the good mushrooms.
Ok I gotcha. Hamburger Helper area. We just zoom by that without looking, might be there in our store. We enjoy Kent Rollins too.
My shrimp and grits recipe as it appeared in the church cookbook:
Fr. Shane's Shrimp and grits​

1 Cup grits
1 Lbs shrimp, peeled and deveined (smaller is better)
2 Cups cheese (something that melts well)
4 Tbsp unsalted butter
2 Anaheim, Poblano, or Hungarian Wax Peppers chopped
½ of an onion chopped
4-5 strips of bacon
Salt
Pepper
Garlic Salt
Paprika
Seafood Seasoning

1. Chop your bacon. Then fry it in a skillet.

2. Put 4 cups of water in a sauce pot. Salt the water (¼ tsp.)

3. Spoon your bacon out of the skillet and set aside. Do not drain the skillet.

4. Add your peppers and onions to the grease in the skillet. Salt and pepper and sweat them down.

5. As your vegetables are cooking, bring your water to a boil. Add the Cup of grits and a ¼ teaspoon of garlic salt.

6. Spoon your vegetables out of the skillet and add them and the bacon to the grits. Do not drain the skillet.

7. Add 1 Tbsp of butter to the grease in the skillet. Then add the shrimp. Season with ½ tsp Garlic Salt and Seafood seasoning to taste. Saute.

8. As your grits are boiling down, add the other 3 Tbsp of butter one at a time. Stir frequently. Also add ½ tsp of pepper and ½ tsp of Paprika.

9. You want the grits to be thickening and the shrimp coming done at about the same time.

10. Empty the contents of the skillet, grease and all, into the pot of grits.

11. Add the cheese a handful at a time and stir moderately until melted. Do this until all the cheese is incorporated. Supper's ready!

Yields several servings.
See less See more
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 4
I've noticed many restaurants are now treating the shrimp component as some sort of topping or sauce. The first time I ever had the dish was at a restaurant on Lady's Island, South Carolina. It seemed to me like they had just mixed it all together. So that's the way I've always made it. And my former organist was a true Southerner, as was her mother, and they both thought it was just fine!

I wrote smaller shrimp is better. My favorite size for this preparation is 51-70. 41-50 also work well.
  • Helpful
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Well, yes because as a topping they use way fewer shrimp than if it was actually a main/primary ingredient.

Cutting costs/less meat/downsizing quantities ALL equals more profit (and more profit means less for the consumer when prices remain the same).

Called "shrinkflation".
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Facepalm
Reactions: 3
Well, yes because as a topping they use way fewer shrimp than if it was actually a main/primary ingredient.

Cutting costs/less meat/downsizing quantities ALL equals more profit (and more profit means less for the consumer when prices remain the same).

Called "shrinkflation".
You are right. Now you can get 8 shrimp and a bowl of grits that cost 30 cents American for $16.99.
  • Wow
Reactions: 1
White or yellow grits for this or does it matter?
White or yellow grits for this or does it matter?
I've never used yellow grits. Never knew of them until you asked. Probably doesn't matter.
1 - 20 of 24 Posts
Top